Honesty is part of expertise. These claims would sell well, but research doesn’t back them:
That reading alone changes behaviour
In the experiments on prosocial behaviour we reviewed, an adult read or led the session. Without an adult, the evidence is mainly for comprehension and vocabulary — and for narrated multimedia stories that children listened to (meta-analysis of 29 studies); independent reading was not tested. Our comic’s effect on behaviour has not yet been tested — which doesn’t mean it doesn’t work; that’s why we will test it.
Takacs et al. 2014; Larsen et al. 2018
That reading “increases empathy”
A meta-analysis of 14 studies (adults) found only a small effect of fiction on social understanding (g ≈ 0.15), and a well-known study in Science did not replicate.
Dodell-Feder & Tamir 2018; Panero et al. 2016
Better grades or a “growth mindset”
Mindset programmes had an average effect on school results of d = 0.05, not significant after correction.
Macnamara & Burgoyne 2023; Sisk et al. 2018
Treating anxiety, ADHD or bullying
Anxiety disorders are treated with cognitive behavioural therapy by a professional. A 2015 review of creative “bibliotherapy” with children included only 8 randomised trials, too varied to combine in a meta-analysis. The comic is not therapy.
James et al. 2020; Montgomery & Maunders 2015
That personalisation teaches by itself
In some small studies with preschoolers, children remembered new words or retold the story better from a personalised book; other studies found no advantage. This hasn’t been tested with older children. The studies we reviewed don’t directly establish that a photo-based cartoon likeness improves learning — so we don’t promise it.
Kucirkova et al. 2014; Neuenschwander et al. 2025; Cho & Yim 2024
That “saying no” prevents abuse
School programmes to prevent sexual abuse mainly improved knowledge (24 studies, 5,802 children); the effect on disclosure is uncertain, and only 2 studies looked at protective behaviour. That’s why, when someone is being hurt, an adult in the story always acts.
Walsh et al. 2015
Myths about “willpower”
A large 23-lab replication of “ego depletion” found d = 0.04, and the link between the marshmallow test and later outcomes shrank by two thirds after accounting for background.
Hagger et al. 2016; Watts et al. 2018